De-cluster Muslims

by Manish Anand

The Indian government has been finally enlightened with the fact that Muslims in India are worse off than scheduled castes (SCs) and scheduled tribes (STs)! Was anyone in India unaware of the fact, which the Sacher Committee has dug out?


Muslims unfortunately have not grown up as community so far and remains waded up into the pre-independence mindset when they had aligned with the Muslim League, for motives which was purely communal. When the SCs and STs kept on making educational and social advancement with keen interest of many co-religious and missionary support, the Muslims in India remained a laid-back community deeply rooted in madrassa based education.


The Central government led by the Congress, which is faced with total erosion of popular support base in North India, is threatening to play the communal card for political purposes. There could be nothing more alarming than the statement of the Prime Minister, Dr Manmohan Singh, hinting at much abused affirmative actions to socially and educationally uplift the Muslims in India.


It has been pointed out many a time that Muslims in India are cursed by them being clustered for political purposes, which exploited the religious insecurity deeply entrenched in the mindset of the Muslim leaders. Abysmal representation of Muslims in government services and judiciary could be ascribed the community still refusing to join the national mainstream. Also, the community could never come up with any socio-religious movement like Arya Samaj, which gave DAV schools and colleges, or many Hindu reform bodies who emphasized on socio-educational reforms in the community. Did any Muslim body come up with any broad-based socio-educational movement, which could have empowered the community effectively?


It must be noted that whereas the middle class and the upper middle class Muslims have been reaching out to the English medium schools even in the interiors of the nation, thus benefiting the fruits of good education, the majority remain still entrenched in madrassa based education, which take away any chance of the community youth to fetch government jobs and place in judiciary. Theirs being the largest in jails for criminal charges has nothing to do with religion but with the socio-economic conditions.


Any affirmative action for the Muslim community by the government taking advantage of the much abused reservation exercise in jo0bs and educational institutions would be fraught with surrendering of the governmental responsibility for exploiting vote-bank opportunity. The community must come out of the shell and join the mainstream. Muslims must be de-clustered. They have to be like Christians, Sikh, and Zorastrians, who are all into the mainstream, and never crib about being under-represented in jobs and judiciary.


However, the first step that the Muslims need to do is to come out of the political and social blindness.

Jaipur jottings

by Manish Anand

A visit to Jaipur recently was a great escape from maddening Delhi. The pink city as it’s called has all the stuff to make other city planners sit and learn. Also, as ideally a city should reflect the culture of its people so does it with all the finesse.

Waiting for a friend to turn up to pick me up at the bus stand, I lent my ears to the lingo of the passersby. Nothing much to hear of those great verbal expletives that Delhi is renowned for and which puts off any newcomer. Also, the people do not shout much as is the case with Delhi where all seem to be patients of high blood pressure.

The next morning as I was being shown the city while my host drove the car, an executive in a private firm, I was told more about the city. What about the traffic? People hardly ignore traffic rules. When some does a group of police men turn up and query with all the politeness. “I could have given Rs 1000 in place of Rs 100 that I was challaned as the cops told in all politeness the reason for the challan,” said my friend.

People hardly use their mobile phones while driving or smoke as cops appear as swiftly as such things are resorted to. Effective policing at its best, must say.

What about city planning?

None of the buildings I saw looked ugly. No encroachments on public land. No parking in front of homes or on road-side, which have seen the service roads virtually disappearing in Delhi. Any violation of building by-laws invite swift demolition action as should be the case.

Yeah, poverty and slums! How could Jaipur remain free of them? As these things can not be solved overnight, the best thing that the city government does is to erect long wall in front of jhuggis with all the art and culture of the state on the display. So, a tourist does not see the stinking slum, and in place sees the art. Great idea isn’t it!

What about the crime?

Very easy to know!. A mere four feet boundary walls around the residences of the people. Security guards hardly visible around the city. The rich and the middle classes have homes alike, and that settles the score on the crime front. But, yes large immigration of people from western Uttar Pradesh and Bihar has unsettled some of the crime figures, and the cops keep an eagle’s eye-view on anything related to these states.

So, what do you think of Jaipur; asked my friend as I readied for Delhi. A great city to be in to enjoy life with all the prides intact was my parting reply.

Garibi hataao?

by Manish Anand

CONGRESS once again is out to lure people in next year mid-term polls in some states and the 2009 Parliamentary polls with the slogan of garibi hataao. The slogan sells and gets people in power, hence the efficacy of the slogan. Unsuspecting half of the population willingly let themselves get fooled by this slogan year after year.

Indira Gandhi gave this slogan in 1971, and since then Congress has always been coming in power to remove poverty (garibi hataao). But poverty stays. It’s not an Opposition party that could be removed by a slogan.

Poverty not only stays but stinks as well. Suicides by farmers in thousands last year, which still continue, though jolted the self-patting economic planners of the nation and mock at the very approach to poverty alleviation.

The cronies of Indira Gandhi had prodded her for such a slogan who knew nothing else to make their master to come in power. The same class, who be default manage the Indian democracy, has again pushed the Indira Gandhi incarnate, Mrs Sonia Gandhi, to exploit the slogan again, and possibly get her son, Mr Rahul Gandhi, elected as the Prime Minister of India, which has been the fiefdom of his family.

Is Congress nervous?

The Congress came into power because its predecessor National Democratic Alliance built a mirage of great economic achievements translating into all round prosperity of all Indians. The bubble burst as farmers started committing suicides in Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra. Poor started selling their children for even Rs 50 in Orissa. All claims of NDA of an economic miracle were rank falsehood sold unashamedly by its suave politicians, which were well read into by the people.

The Congress is in the same position after three years of governance. Two years is a very short period to correct the chronic flaw of Indian economy.

Farmers are still committing suicide in Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh. Children are still sold in Orissa. Uttar Pradesh and Bihar buried Congress long back for its utter political exploitation of these two states without bothering to economically better people there.

So, Congress has every reason to be nervous, and that too when the Rahul baba is to be handed over the political future of the Congress.

Early this year the finance minister P Chidambaram had dropped in a shopping mall in Noida with his family to watch a movie in one of its movie place. He was astounded to see so many people shopping. The next day he declared that lots of people are buying, and that shows that India is really growing fast! No finance minister in India unfortunately visits the interior of the nation.

Where is the time from the endless meeting with big corporate heads, representatives of World Bank and IMF, etc. Also, finance ministers are hardly repeated. So, the cool comfort of the South Block besots the minister all the time. And, all news of the finance of India in mess irritates him, calling journalists illiterate and ill-informed.

What ills Indian economy?

Isn’t Indian economy all for the middle men? Profiteering middle class has made the most of the new economy, leaving the lower strata getting deeper and deeper in poverty. Everybody cried get the poor to save money. Grow their incomes. Corporatise farm sector has been the call for the last one decade, but for no result other then of snatching the land of the farmer at throwaway price.

Details are all in public domain about answers to the woes of Indian economy. But a class which comes in power on the basis of sloganeering remains convinced that sloganeering could be milked further. So, nothing to worry if more and more people migrate from rural hinterlands to end up living an 18th century miserable industrial lives, it hardly matters to the political class.

Another election preparation, and again the need to go back to the time tested plank. Garibi hataao with some 20 point programme, which is nothing but fraud on the Indian poor, gets unrolling. Let’s see if the Congress could succeed in fooling people once again.

Hang Afzal, damn it!

by Manish Anand


Indians are the most apologetic of the people. Even when its sovereignty is attacked, it dithers whether to punish the culprit or not. Emotionally weak are those who lead the nation, and suffer from rank indecisiveness. Having short memory, its people yield to emotional chorus for mercy for perpetrators of heinous crimes.


The president Dr APJ Abdul Kalam has referred the mercy petition of the wife of Mohammad Afzal to the home secretary, and that stays the scheduled hanging of Afzal on 20 October as of now. Afzal is charged with waging war against the nation as he orchestrated terrorist attack on Parliament, which resulted in seven deaths, including of four security personnel. The attack also brought India and Pakistan close to a full-blown war.


Now, with the Special Court having held him accused and condemned him to death by hanging, the media suave colleague of him swung into action to save him. SAR Geelani, also accused in the same case, commands impressive media audience, and has stepped up efforts in this regard. The Jammu & Kashmir has been painted again in rebellious colour with its renegade politicians making Afzal a martyr for its freedom cause. The Congress leaders as weak as ever have been bowled over by the hue and cry made in the valley. The Congress High Command advisors have equally developed cold feet over hanging of Afzal.


So, where do we go?


The home secretary is expected to turn down the mercy petition. Because, pardon will portray the nation again as a soft nation, which she has been fighting hard to wriggle out of. The eyeball to eyeball response post-Parliament attack was to assert that India is not to tolerate the Pakistani design of giving her hundred cuts. And, attack on the symbol of soverignty was just intolerable. All these haapen just four years ago, not long back.


If Kashmiris really need martyrs, they can get hundreds of them as terrorists get killed by security personnel in the valley. The portrayal of Afzal as a martyr is again a voice typical of those who dream of merging with Pakistan, hoping that they would get an Islamic umbrella to enjoy fruits of life with dignity. The Congress leaders in Jammu & Kashmir as well as those of its alliance partner People's Democratic Front had always dubious credentials about their loyalty to the Indian nation-hood.


Think of those who shed blood in the name of saving the dignity of the Indian motherhood from the nefarious design of her enemies. Thousands of security personnel have laid down their lives thwarting Pakistani attempts. Their children not beaten down still dream of getting opportunity to serve for the cause of Indian nationalism, which is of course an idiotic concept for the burly aristocratic bureaucrats, feeding on British arrogance, as well as by the new class for whom the best in life is all that America has.


Damn it! Get tough against those who kill and maim innocents. Highest crime is waging war against the nation. And, for highest crime, we have capital punishment. So, go ahead and execute Afzal.


Huh, what about the neo-liberals, who call for scraping of capital punishment. Europian Union has done so, and hence India too should do so! Just tell these people to pack off to EU, because India is not Europe. India is a nation, which is always at war with its neighbours, who are well entrenched deep into India to inflict innumerable cuts upon her. Let there be a credible permanent peace, and then we would debate if we could do away with capital punishment. Till then just shut up, and let the law reach its logical conclusion.


Just hang this bloody Afzal for the sake of instilling deterrance in terrorists.